The retail property market in the United States is confronting significant challenges in 2025, marking a departure from the multi-year recovery seen in previous years. Key factors contributing to this downturn include high-profile bankruptcies of major retailers, a slowdown in leasing activity, and broader economic uncertainties.
Bankruptcies and Store Closures
Several prominent retailers have filed for bankruptcy or announced store closures, leading to an increase in vacant retail spaces. Companies such as Big Lots, Party City, and Joann have been among the most notable closures. These bankruptcies have left landlords with the challenge of filling large spaces previously occupied by these tenants.
Decline in Leasing Activity
According to Cushman & Wakefield, the first quarter of 2025 saw retailers vacate nearly 6 million more square feet of space than they leased, representing the weakest leasing activity since the onset of the pandemic. This decline in leasing activity is indicative of a broader slowdown in the retail sector, as businesses become more cautious in their expansion plans amid economic uncertainties.
Economic Factors Impacting the Retail Sector
Inflation and economic uncertainty have further dampened consumer spending and tenant demand. Rising costs have led to reduced disposable income for consumers, affecting their purchasing behavior and, consequently, the demand for retail space. Additionally, the potential for further tariff-driven price hikes has added to the cost pressures faced by retailers, contributing to market instability.
Selective Expansion Amidst Challenges
Despite the challenges, some retailers continue to pursue selective expansion. Companies like Burlington and Five Below are actively seeking new locations, particularly in areas with lower operational costs. However, their expansion strategies are more cautious and targeted, focusing on markets that offer favorable conditions for growth.
Shift in Negotiating Power
The current market dynamics have shifted negotiating power back to tenants. With an increase in available retail space and a slowdown in leasing activity, tenants now have more leverage in negotiations with landlords. This shift has led to more favorable lease terms for tenants, including lower rents and more flexible agreements.
Outlook for the Remainder of 2025
The outlook for the retail property sector for the remainder of 2025 remains challenging. While some improvements have occurred in the mall segment, overall market conditions suggest a continued period of adjustment. Landlords may need to adapt to the evolving retail landscape by considering alternative uses for vacant spaces and exploring opportunities in emerging retail formats.
Conclusion
The retail property market in 2025 is navigating a complex landscape characterized by increased vacancies, cautious expansion, and shifting tenant dynamics. Stakeholders in the retail real estate sector will need to remain adaptable and responsive to these changes to navigate the challenges ahead.